The chart below combines the scores from the individual performance metrics to give an overall view of how the SoftBottle (shown in blue) compared to its competitors.
Ease of Use
The SoftBottle has a collapsible plastic body and screw-on cap. It has a simple design and only two parts, making it easy to operate. The lid is small and opaque, which definitely runs the risk of becoming misplaced, but as we found out during testing, if you do lose the lid, it is easy to order a replacement online for only a few extra bucks. Another plus for this contender is that it forms to the space available in your pack for easy stowing. The flexible body is also helpful when filling the bottle in shallow streams in the backcountry. It is leak-proof beyond any doubt, and easily rolls up and fits into your pocket when empty.
On the down side, drinking from this collapsable bottle requires a learned skill, and definitely needs two hands. Its soft flexibility makes it flop around when trying to grab a drink, which will lead to spills if you're not careful. This is defnitely not a one-handed drinking bottle, but if you're using this bottle, hopefully you are in the backcountry or on some kind of adventure where you will have time to use both hands to hydrate yourself! The bottle also tied with the Soma Bottle as the easiest to tip over. This is yet another factor that makes the Platypus better suited for the great outdoors than as your work or commute companion.
This contender also has the smallest mouth of all bottles we tested, making it hard to fill up from faucets with large or powerful water streams. On this note, if you are planning on purifying your water, the Platypus requires a different bottle for purification with a filter or a Steri-Pen, which should be noted if you're planning on taking this bottle into the backcountry. It works well as a back-up, but needs another bottle for filling and purification.
Drinking from this water bottle tasted fine at first. However, if you store your water in this bottle for over 24 hours, expect it to have a plastic-y taste. It also retained the taste of the flavored sports drink in subsequent fills. We recommend filling the SoftBottle only with water. This is the downside of the bottle being plastic, and collapsable as the mailable plastic seems to impart its flavor on the liquid more than solid plastic bottles, like the Nalgene or CamelBak Eddy
The SoftBottle also retained a strong taste of soap after washing it. We experienced the same problem with the Nomader BPA Free Collapsable bottle. We were able to return the bottle to a neutral taste after filling it with baking soda and vinegar for 12 hours and rinsing. The best way to use these malleable plastic bottles is to simply use them for drinking water and try not to get other flavors imparted into their plastic walls. For a bottle that does not retain taste, we recommend checking out the Hydro Flask Wide-Mouth
, our Editors' Choice winner, or the Lifefactory Glass
or Soma Water Bottle
; all three scored a 9 out of 10 in terms of not having a plastic taste or holding flavors.
The SoftBottle can easily handle your average tumble onto hard surfaces. It breezed through our drop tests, barely suffering a scratch (a minute scratch on the cap was all). However, you can't expect a collapsible bottle to last forever. It held up fine in our three-month review, but in personal experience, we haven't had a collapsible bottle that held up much more than a year. For this reason, we recommend always having another water container as a backup. If you fold the bottle up for storage frequently, the bottle will wear more quickly along the fold lines and could risk having a hole form on the seam.
Even so, the Platypus bottle is more durable than the Nomader
because of its simple design; only two parts (lid and body) make up the Platypus. The Nomader may be more durable in its body, but its lid has so many plastic parts that it seems that the bottle will wear out much faster than a the Platypus, with its simple design.
The Platypus SoftBottle in comparison to its collapsible neighbor, the Nomader. The Platypus is much more collapsible, but the Nomader is easier to drink from.
Ease of Cleaning
This contender was pretty difficult to clean. You'll need a specialized, expensive brush if you want to really get in there. Without such a brush, it took us an average three minutes and 30 seconds to hand wash this bottle. Other bottles, with wide mouths especially (the Nalgene Wide-Mouth
, Hydro Flask Wide-Mouth Insulated
, or CamelBak Eddy), were much easier to clean, but lacked the probability of the Platypus. That being said, you probably won't be filling this bottle up with coffee or flavorful teas, and a light rinse is enough to get it clean in the backcountry, so it cleans well enough for the settings it is most comfortable in.
The SoftBottle was the weight weenie champion in this metric at 1.3 ounces, weighing the least of the bottles we reviewed. That works out to being only four hundredths of an ounce per fluid ounce. You'll notice the water in your backpack, but not the bottle. There are no bottles that came close in comparison to this contender in terms of weight. It is in this category that the bottle really shines. Other lightweight bottle options are the Nalgene Wide-Mouth
or the CamelBak Eddy
, both of which weight in at around 6 oz, making them light, but still nearly 5 oz heavier than the Platypus.
The SoftBottle will serve you best in the backcountry. It stows neatly, it's very light, and can handle rugged treatment. This product makes a great back-up reservoir and even better primary vessel when equipped with an auxiliary drinking tube. You can even fold it up and fit it in your back pocket, making it the most portable bottle we tested.
Great for traveling because it packs down to nothing, the Platypus fits pretty much anywhere.
At $9, the Platypus SoftBottle is a great value bottle for those of us who frequently go on multi-day trips. It is packable and light, and easy to fill from streams. That being said, the value of this bottle significantly drops when using it in the office as your primary bottle. It doesn't stand up well on its own, much like the Soma Bottle- one of our glass contenders. The Platypus is by far the most inexpensive bottle on the list, but the runners-up are the Nalgene Wide Mouth, the Citrus Zinger
, and the CamelBak Eddy
. These all ring in at $16, but are far more durable and substantial than the Platypus for use around town.
The Platypus SoftBottle is an ideal bottle for backpacking and traveling. Its lightweight design that makes it nearly perfect for these uses also adds to the drawbacks of the SoftBottle in use around town. The flexible body can collapse into the size of a plastic bag and stows away easily. On the downside, the bottle has trouble standing up on its own on a table and is nearly impossible to drink from using only one hand. For only $9, though, the Platypus SoftBottle is an inexpensive, ideal bottle for those planning on spending lots of time in the backcountry or on hiking trips where pack space and weight are concerns.