sidebar

OutdoorGearLab Home

search
Review | Ratings | Buying Tips | Testing

How to Choose the Best Pocket Knife

The full-size  utilitarian blade of the SwissChamp will slice through food  rope  textiles  wood. Whatever you ask of it. This slender cutter does far more than you can imagine it would.
By Jediah Porter ⋅ Review Editor
Tuesday September 20, 2016


How do you narrow down a dizzyingly complex field of pocket knives to make your choice? A pocket knife is one tool that even the least "handy" person may use every day. Choosing one that fits seamlessly into your life and increases your overall life productivity is a worthy task. After testing a narrow and competitive field of eight of the best pocket knives available we have come to better understand how you should work through your own choice.

Why Carry a Pocket Knife?


Why carry a knife? In short  because every 8 year old boy wants to  it must be a good idea.
Why carry a knife? In short, because every 8 year old boy wants to, it must be a good idea.
Pocket knives are, by definition, a general purpose tool. The category is united by the suitability of the tool for carrying in a pants pocket. You may choose to carry it elsewhere, but the knife is sized and designed to be in your pants pocket for easy access. A knife need to be portable and accessible this way for a variety of tasks. Specialized knives for hunting, fishing, box-cutting, kitchen use, drywall, etc, do not need to be carried in a pocket. Therefore, their design limitations are different.

Navigating the minefield of knives on the market is much like figuring out what this photo represents. How many tools are there? Which is which? How do I find what I want?
Navigating the minefield of knives on the market is much like figuring out what this photo represents. How many tools are there? Which is which? How do I find what I want?

Overall Considerations


First of all, do you identify yourself as a "handy" person? Do you seek out creative and self-reliant solutions to life's mechanical problems? Those of you who answer yes to this question will undoubtedly find a use for a pocket knife at least once every day. You will also take pride in the tool you carry, and easily justify pocket or purse space for a functional knife. Using a well-made, purpose built and at-the-ready pocket knife for daily tasks is an aesthetically pleasing experience. The subtle swell of pride in employing something like our Editors' Choice Award-winning Benchmade Mini-Barrage 585 in a productive fashion is unmatched in a world dominated by a great deal of "screen time" and virtual victories.

If you'll carry a knife for general purpose  and can keep track of an expensive piece of small equipment  you'll do very well with our Editors Choice Benchmade Mini Barrage 585.
If you'll carry a knife for general purpose, and can keep track of an expensive piece of small equipment, you'll do very well with our Editors Choice Benchmade Mini Barrage 585.
Pocket knives are easily lost. Those of you on a first-name basis with your locksmith should consider replacement cost when purchasing a pocket knife. If you regularly replace car and house keys well before the sheen is worn off, find a readily available and inexpensive design that you like. Inexpensive pocket knives still serve the purpose. The difference between the blade steel of a cheaper knife and that in a spendy tool like the Benchmade Griptilian 551 is noticeable, but marginal given the difference in price. A cheaper tool will need sharpening a little more regularly (every three months vs. every four, perhaps). The primary difference, as outlined in our main article, is in a far more subjective and aesthetic sense. Those of you multi-tasking enough to lose knives frequently are also too busy to care if the knife blade "feels" good cutting through the box of your eighteenth eBay purchase this week.

Also, in terms of losing knives, consider how you will carry it. Especially if you are new to carrying a knife for everyday use, integrating it with your ever-present keys is a good way to train yourself to keep track of it. You already have habits, effective or sometimes not, that keep the keys nearby. Your average bundle of keys will take on little additional bulk with something like our Top Pick Victorinox Classic SD Swiss Army Knife. Aside from key-chain carry, the primary knife-security feature is the pocket clip. Most of the knives in our test are equipped this way. The knife lives inside a pocket, with a spring-steel metal clip securing it to the outside of the pants. The clip is indeed visible, but barely. And the knife remains easily in reach and secured regardless of position.

Categories of Usage


Even in the huge field of knives designed for general, everyday carriage in a pants pocket, there is a great deal of variation. Inherently, different design considerations and usage priorities differentiate the field. Here at OutdoorGearLab, we organize the options by differentiating between how you'll use a knife. The vast majority of knives are purchased for routine, "urban" if you will, daily usage. However, our OGL readers are interested in outdoors applications as well. Given all that, we've lumped our buying advice into the following categories.

Every Day Carry
This is the big category. Most knife owners purchase their pocket blade for omnipresent carriage. Your knife will become a comforting and aesthetic part of each day. You will find more and more uses for it. You will, if the habit is new to you, risk losing it at first but quickly get to the point where, like your cell phone, you feel naked without the knife in its usual spot. You will use it enough to appreciate sound ergonomics and impeccable construction. In any event, you'll want a just-less-than-full-size, round-handled folder. If you have sound pocket organizational habits, we can unequivocally recommend our Editors' Choice Benchmade Mini-Barrage 585. If you are a little sloppy, losing keys before the sheen wears off, shop around for something of similar dimensions at a fraction of the price. Something you won't be as sad to lose.

Every Day Carry and Backcountry Usage
Backcountry users are practical  and concerned with weight and bulk. You'll want a durable  usable tool for in town  but want to make sure its small and light if you'll carry it very far.
Backcountry users are practical, and concerned with weight and bulk. You'll want a durable, usable tool for in town, but want to make sure its small and light if you'll carry it very far.
If you intend to use the knife in the back country, weight and bulk become far more important. Sure, carrying a knife every day requires ensuring that its bulk won't interfere. However, front country users are far less fanatical about the grams than back country travelers. Our Best Buy Kershaw Leek could be just the ticket for folks in this category. It's ergonomic and durable enough for everyday usage, but compact and light for extended hikes and climbing.

Just Backcountry Usage
If you'll use your knife only in the backcountry  consider something ultra compact like the Gerber STL Fine Edge 2.0.
If you'll use your knife only in the backcountry, consider something ultra compact like the Gerber STL Fine Edge 2.0.
Perhaps your knife will live in your backpack or first aid kit. You'll use it to cut cheese, climbing webbing, and the occasional light repair task. As compared to every day carry, you're far less apt to misplace this knife. And you're going to use it less often. In our review, the Gerber STL 2.0 Fine Edge is an excellent backcountry knife. It is tiny and durable, with a functional blade.

Every Day Carry and Hunting or Fishing
Hunting and fishing require durable  sharp tools that clean up easily.
Hunting and fishing require durable, sharp tools that clean up easily.
If one hunts or fishes a great deal alongside the roads, having a dedicated, purpose-built knife is just the ticket. Fixed blade hunting knives and long, slender fillet knives are designed for a reason. However, if you need a backup, or will be hunting and fishing deep in the back country, many every day folding pocket knife designs can be employed to good effect. The primary special consideration one should look to address is simplicity of construction and ease of cleaning. Use of a folding knife in dressing game and fish is a messy proposition. Tools with additional features and spring-loaded assisted opening function will get gunked up unnecessarily. Simple and sharp folders like the Benchmade Griptilian 551 are perfect for the user who also participates in the more "consumptive" forms of outdoor recreation.

Every Day Carry and Home Handiwork
If you'll use your knife for handiwork tasks  consider feature-filled Swiss Army Knife styles. Or consult our Multi-Tool Review.
If you'll use your knife for handiwork tasks, consider feature-filled Swiss Army Knife styles. Or consult our Multi-Tool Review.
Finally, you may choose to carry a knife for general usage but live in a "fixer upper" of a home. Or you work in a field that requires the occasional improvised field repair. Or you are simply a handy type, making "for some reason" numerous little fixes and improvements in your day-to-day and week-to-week life. If you are handy enough, any simple blade can be forced to do a great number of tasks. However, occasionally you will need more specialized tools. For that application, peruse our Multi-Tool Review to see if something there suits you.

Other Features


After addressing the big questions of how and where you will use your knife and how much you are willing to spend, it is worth giving consideration to the smaller and additional features of a knife. However, first a reminder. This is a huge field of equipment. There are literally hundreds of knives on the market, with vintage and discontinued equipment also virtually ubiquitous and still fully relevant. In each of the above categories, there are at least 30-40 knives available. You'll find knives at every price point and with every combination of other features. These other functions can be divided into two major categories. Look for the modularity of a knife and for subtleties in the hinging mechanisms.

When we discuss modularity of a pocket knife, we're talking about the ability to tweak the knife to exactly suit your purposes. Some knives are equipped to swap out blades. High-end knives can be completely rebuilt, usually by the manufacturer or an experienced technician. The pocket clip on many knives can be removed by the user. In some of those cases the pocket clip can be remounted on the opposite side, or even on the opposite end of the handle. This movable pocket clip allows the user to set it up for carry in either pocket while still being easily manipulated upon deployment.

All pocket knives have at least one blade that folds into the handle. Virtually all knives have some sort of spring to hold the blade open, at least under light pressure. Some knives add in an additional lock. In order to close the blade of locking knives, one must hold some sort of tab open while simultaneously closing the blade. This protects the user's hand while the knife is in heavy use. Some knives add in secondary locks as well. In these knives, two steps are required to close the knife. . We find this level of protection to be unnecessarily complicated. We tested no knives with secondary locking mechanisms. We like simple "liner" style locking mechanisms. This is a clean and proven feature. There is simply a tab inside the handle and alongside the blade that stays flexed out of the way while the blade is closed. When the blade is opened and reaches full length, the tab springs out to block the closure of the blade. The user simply and intentionally flexes the tab out of the way before closing the blade. Benchmade knives use their own proprietary blade lock. It works just fine also. Some knives are made to lock closed also. In crowded pockets, especially with assisted opening knives, this can be a valuable feature. Realize, however, that a blade locked closed often negates much of the effort the manufacturer has exerted to make the knife open more quickly.

A series of photos documenting the assisted opening function of the Mini Barrage. Note that the spring eventually pulls the blade out ahead of the users thumb. In short  you just need to get it going and the spring does the rest.
A series of photos documenting the assisted opening function of the Mini Barrage. Note that the spring eventually pulls the blade out ahead of the users thumb. In short, you just need to get it going and the spring does the rest.
Finally, consider the value you may experience with an assisted opening knife. Assisted opening knives, as the descriptive label suggests, are equipped with springs that help pull the blade to full extension. The user gets the blade moving, usually with a thumb-stud on the base of the blade, and the springs quickly "take over" and pull the blade the rest of the way out. Our testers appreciate this function and uniformly preferred those knives thus equipped. Deploying the blade for simple and quick tasks is more efficient. If one carries a knife for efficiency and convenience, it follows that an assisted opening feature will further enhance the experience. The assisted opening mechanism in a knife adds just a little cost and complication to the construction.

Wondering how you can keep your pocket knife clean and sharpened? Read How to Clean A Pocket Knife and How to Sharpen A Pocket Knife.

Jediah Porter
About the Author
Jediah Porter is a full-time part-timer. He works as a mountain guide and for OutdoorGearLab and as a substitute teacher. Guiding work requires an even mix of rock shoes, approach shoes, ice boots, and ski gear. Off the clock, he climbs and skis. He also engages in binges of mountain biking, canoeing, hunting, fishing, and trail-running. He goes by Jed and takes pride in using the right tool for the job, unless he doesn't have that tool. In which case he improvises. "If you don't have it, you don't need it". He has lived most of his adult life in the Eastern Sierra and tries to get to Alaska (for big mountains) and the East Coast (for family) once each year. Jed's web site is www.jediahporter.com

You Might Also Like