While the fit itself was perfectly fine, wearing this jacket made one feel as if they were wearing a large overcoat, insulated and cut off from the outside world. While we need a hardshell to protect us from the weather, it is also critical for the mountain and outdoor sports that we play that our clothing works with us, moving as we move, something this jacket didn't do very well, and in stark contrast to our Best Overall Hardshell, also made with GORE-TEX Pro, the Arc'teryx Alpha FL
While we tested this jacket with many runs in the powder in the backcountry, we think it is best used as a resort skiing hardshell.
We loved the long, low hem of this jacket, combined with the internal powder skirt, for how well it performed keeping out the deep powder. However, in our shower test, we noticed that this jacket suffered by far the most wetting out of the face fabric of any jacket after our test period. This means that the DWR coating applied to the outside of this jacket had mostly worn off, making it perhaps the poorest quality DWR coating of the review.
As a warm, protective jacket, this one thrives on days like this where the snow is blowing sideways. It has an expansive enough fit that it is easy to layer beneath.
More problematic, however, was the fact that just like the Fuseform Jacket
, and the Patagonia Triolet
, the hood was ineffective at channeling the water from a severe downpour off the sides of the head. Instead, water poured over the brim of the hood, and also ran down the edges and easily washed down the inside of the collar and jacket. As a skiing specific jacket, heavy rain should not be a top concern, but you never know… We couldn't give this jacket more than 6 points for weather protection, despite its top-quality membrane.
Showing the face fabric after the intense downpour of our shower test. As you can see, some areas are still protected by the DWR coating, while other areas have wetted out.
Weight and Packability
On our scale, this jacket weighed 24.7 ounces for a size men's medium, making it the heaviest jacket in the review. It was also the largest jacket in the review when all rolled up and packed away, meaning it was the least packable. If you're not wearing this jacket, you certainly don't want to be carrying it with you.
A select sample of the differences in packable size between jackets. On the bottom is the Arc'teryx Alpha FL in its stuff sack. In the middle, almost as small, is the Black Diamond Helio Alpine Shell rolled into its hood -- again, very small. On the top is the heavy and bulky TNF Free Thinker jacket, more than double the size and weight of the one on the bottom.
Mobility and Fit
The large, free flowing fit of this jacket, exemplified by the low hem line, was one of the positive features we loved. Like the Fuseform
, and also the Outdoor Research Furio
, we felt that the sleeves were simply too short. However, this is not such a big problem for a skiing-only jacket as it is when you are planning to go ice climbing. We thought the fit was larger and more spacious than just about any jacket we tested, but in a good way, and we were always able to comfortably layer beneath it. What we didn't like was how stiff, crinkly, and immobile feeling the combination of the GORE_TEX Pro membrane with the 70D face fabric was. A jacket like the Arc'teryx Beta AR
was able to use the same membrane in conjunction with face fabrics just as durable while still retaining fluid and easy movement, something that was missing with the Free Thinker
. 7 out of 10 points.
Backcountry skiing in the San Juan mountains was the primary means of testing this skiing-specific jacket. You can see the low cut of the hem and how it protects the lower torso from powder invasions.
Venting and Breathability
We appreciated that The North Face's marketing claims about this jacket told the story as it is, and didn't throw around a lot of words like "lightweight" or "skinning uphill" when describing this jacket. The truth is, despite using a highly breathable membrane, this jacket is heavy and hot, great traits for keeping warm at a ski resort, but terrible attributes for the backcountry enthusiast. While this jacket does have pit zips, they are much smaller than the average found on the Black Diamond Helio Alpine Shell
, and only have one zipper instead of the ubiquitous two. The venting options on this jacket almost seem like an after-thought, and are nothing like the very well designed options found on the Outdoor Research Furio
or Rab Latok Alpine Jacket
. In the end, we gave it a low 5 out of 10 points for venting and breathability.
Testing the breathability of the GORE-TEX Pro membrane in this jacket by taking it for a spin on the nordic trails. In general we found this jacket to be heavy and warm, and to not ventilate very well.
Draw cord pull loops like these are accessible both on the outside of the jacket, shown here, as well as inside the collar. While we liked the choice, we found them to be among the least effective hood draw cords, one of our few complaints with the features found on this jacket.
This jacket was clearly designed with downhill skiing in mind. The only noticeable differences were the location of the chest pockets (lower and wider on the body) and the design of the wrist cuffs. We loved the forearm pocket with goggle wipe, integrated powder skirt, internal stash pockets, and internal zip pockets with media port. What we didn't enjoy as much was the difficult-to-adjust front hood drawcords and the gigantic Velcro wrist enclosures.
Shown here is the grey GORE-TEX Pro membrane interior backing, as well as one of the mesh interior stash pockets and the blue powder skirt with buttons for attaching it across the waist in the front.
These wrist enclosures are clearly designed to wrap the wrist over the top of the ski glove, but we tend to like ski gloves with wrist sleeves, which make it easier to keep the snow out. We had a very hard time fitting the wrists of this jacket into our gloves, and feel that a much smaller and simpler wrist enclosure, like our favorites found on the Arc'teryx Alpha FL
and Beta AR
, work much better to accomplish the same thing. Our battles with these wrist cuffs inspired us to give one less point than we awarded to the Fuseform
, 8 out of 10.
While the overly large Velcro tabs on the wrists of this jacket certainly worked, they were too big to easily fit under the sleeves of our ski gloves, something we repeatedly battled with.
One of the many skiing specific features of this jacket is a forearm sleeve pocket with tethered goggle wipe inside.
This jacket is designed with skiing in mind and would make a great coat for riding at the resorts, or if you happen to be lucky enough to have a heli drop at the top of some remote mountain range that we all dream about. It is not designed for alpine climbing, mountaineering, or skinning uphill, but we still wanted to see how it compared to the all-around jackets we typically test in this review. While it was one of the lower scorers in our comparison review and based on the metrics we value, we still think it is a worthy jacket for downhill skiing.
Storm skiing means limited visibility. Here testing the Free Thinker jacket with low contrast conditions. This jacket offers great protection from blizzards like this one.
This jacket retails at an astronomically high $599, making it the most expensive in this review. Also, our favorite jacket, the Arc'teryx Alpha FL
, uses the same GORE-TEX Pro membrane and costs over $200 less. The point is while this is a well made and durable jacket, there are far more cost-effective options out there that ranked much higher in our comparison testing.
The North Face Free Thinker Jacket
is a top-end skiing jacket best used at the resorts when the weather has turned truly apocalyptic. It is not a good choice for trying to climb mountains in, and should be considered only if you need a high-end hardshell for skiing. While it is a well-made jacket that has some worthy features, many other jackets in this review are likely to serve the reader better.
There is no doubt that this jacket offers fantastic protection from the blowing snow and wind found on this backcountry tour, although it can get real toasty skinning uphill while fully zipped up.